Valerian vs Passionflower for Perimenopause: Sleep and Anxiety Support
Valerian vs passionflower for perimenopause sleep and anxiety. Compare how each herb works, what the evidence shows, and which might be better suited to your symptoms.
Why Herbal Sleep Aids Come Up in Perimenopause
Sleep disruption and anxiety are among the most commonly reported symptoms of perimenopause. Night sweats aside, many women find that their nervous system becomes more reactive during this transition, making it harder to fall asleep, stay asleep, or feel calm during the day. Valerian and passionflower are two of the most widely used herbal remedies for these concerns, and they work through different mechanisms.
How Valerian Works
Valerian root contains compounds that appear to interact with GABA receptors in the brain, similar in principle to how some prescription sedatives work, though much more mildly. It is primarily used for sleep onset, reducing the time it takes to fall asleep and improving overall sleep quality. Some evidence also suggests modest benefits for anxiety. It typically takes one to four weeks of regular use to notice consistent effects, and the smell and taste are notoriously strong, which some people find off-putting.
How Passionflower Works
Passionflower also acts on the GABA system, and some clinical trials have found it effective for generalised anxiety and insomnia. It tends to be milder and better tolerated than valerian. Many women find passionflower particularly helpful for anxious, racing thoughts that prevent sleep, as well as for daytime nervous tension. It is often described as creating a sense of calm without sedation, making it more suitable for use during the day if anxiety is the primary concern.
Key Differences
Valerian is generally considered stronger and more sedating, making it better suited to sleep onset problems. Passionflower is gentler, more versatile for daytime anxiety, and often easier to take in tea form. The two are frequently combined in herbal sleep formulas precisely because their effects are complementary. Neither herb has the same volume of clinical evidence as pharmaceutical options, but both have a reasonable safety record and long histories of traditional use.
Who Each Suits
Valerian may suit you if your main issue is getting to sleep and you are happy taking a capsule or tablet at night. Passionflower may suit you better if anxiety is a significant part of your experience and you want something you can use flexibly across the day as well as at night. If your sleep problems are primarily driven by night sweats rather than anxiety or difficulty winding down, neither herb will address the root cause, and a conversation about hormonal support may be more worthwhile.
Things to Know Before Starting
Both herbs can interact with sedative medications and should be used with caution if you take sleep aids, anti-anxiety drugs, or antihistamines. Discuss with your GP or pharmacist before starting either. Tracking your sleep quality and anxiety levels before and after starting a supplement gives you useful evidence about whether it is helping. PeriPlan's symptom log can be used for exactly this kind of before-and-after tracking.
Related reading
Get your personalized daily plan
Track symptoms, match workouts to your day type, and build a routine that adapts with you through every phase of perimenopause.