Oestrogel vs HRT Patches: Which Transdermal Oestrogen Suits You?
Comparing oestrogel and HRT patches for perimenopause: absorption, dose flexibility, skin reactions, and exercise considerations to discuss with your prescriber.
Two Routes to the Same Destination
Both oestrogel and HRT patches deliver oestrogen through the skin, bypassing the liver and avoiding the blood clot and stroke risk associated with oral oestrogen tablets. This transdermal route is now widely recommended, particularly for women with cardiovascular risk factors or those who prefer a lower-risk profile. Despite sharing this core mechanism, oestrogel and patches differ meaningfully in how they are applied, how doses are adjusted, and how they interact with everyday life. Understanding these differences helps you have a more informed conversation with your prescriber.
How Oestrogel Works
Oestrogel (estradiol gel) is applied to the skin of the inner arm, thigh, or lower abdomen once daily. You spread a measured number of pump doses, typically one to four pumps, over a relatively large skin area and allow it to dry for a couple of minutes before dressing. Absorption is gradual and delivers a steady level of oestrogen throughout the day. One practical advantage is dose flexibility: if your prescriber wants to increase or reduce your dose, it is a simple adjustment of pump strokes. This makes oestrogel a useful option during perimenopause when hormonal needs can shift over time. Gel is also a good choice if you have a nickel sensitivity, since patches use adhesives that some women find irritating.
How Patches Work
HRT patches come in two main types. Matrix patches embed the hormone directly into the adhesive layer, so the oestrogen releases through the adhesive itself. Reservoir patches have a separate hormone-containing compartment with a membrane that controls release. Most modern patches are matrix type, which tend to be thinner and more discreet. Patches are worn continuously for either two or three and a half days before being replaced, depending on the brand. They are usually applied to the lower abdomen, buttock, or hip, avoiding the waistband area and breasts. The dose is fixed for each patch, so changing doses means switching to a different strength patch.
Adherence and Skin Reactions
Adherence, whether a patch stays on reliably, is the most common practical concern. Patches can lift at the edges during hot weather, sweating, or if applied to skin that was recently moisturised. Skin reactions at the adhesive site, ranging from mild redness to persistent irritation, affect a minority of users but are more frequent with patches than with gel. Rotating the application site each time can reduce irritation. Oestrogel avoids the adhesive issue entirely, though it requires a consistent daily routine and the product must dry fully before contact with clothing or another person, as gel can transfer to a partner or child through skin-to-skin contact.
Swimming, Exercise, and Practical Considerations
Active women often ask whether patches stay on during swimming and exercise. Most matrix patches are designed to remain in place during normal swimming and showering, though edge lifting can occur with prolonged immersion. If patch loss is a recurring problem, some women apply a small transparent wound dressing over the patch edge to help it stay. Oestrogel presents no waterproofing concern since it is applied in the morning and fully absorbed before swimming. For women who exercise intensively and sweat heavily, oestrogel may be the lower-maintenance choice simply because there is nothing to stay stuck.
Dose Flexibility and Hormonal Stability
Oestrogel allows finer-grained dose titration. If you are trying to find the lowest effective dose, small adjustments are straightforward. This is particularly useful in perimenopause, where symptom severity fluctuates and the ideal dose may change over months or years. Patches provide more consistent blood levels over their wear period because the membrane or adhesive releases hormone at a controlled rate. Some women find this consistency produces more stable symptom relief, while others prefer the flexibility of gel. Neither form is universally superior: the best choice depends on your skin, your routine, your symptoms, and how your body responds.
What to Discuss with Your Prescriber
When choosing between oestrogel and patches, it helps to bring specific information to your appointment. If you have had skin reactions to plasters or adhesives in the past, mention this. If you swim regularly or find daily routines difficult to maintain, say so. If you want finer dose control during an unpredictable perimenopausal period, that is a relevant factor. Logging your symptoms before and after starting HRT, which you can do in an app like PeriPlan, helps you track patterns and give your prescriber objective data rather than impressions. Most prescribers are willing to trial one form and switch if it does not suit you, so the first choice is not permanent.
Related reading
Get your personalized daily plan
Track symptoms, match workouts to your day type, and build a routine that adapts with you through every phase of perimenopause.